Hope Believed

An Easter sermon from Calvary Presbyterian Church in San Francisco, California.

April 17, 2022

Luke 24:1-12

The gospel writers don’t agree about every detail as they tell the story of Jesus. Joann mentioned that Thursday when talking about the accounts of the night Jesus was betrayed.

One thing all four gospel writers record is that women were the first people to the tomb on Easter morning.

The women had been there all along, of course.

They followed the procession to the cross, crying and keening as they went.

They stood vigil and watched as Jesus died.

They accompanied Joseph of Arimathea as Jesus was buried, laid in the tomb.

But now they are there, alone. They have gone to the tomb in the early morning hours to anoint his body, to extend the care and affection we show to our loved ones when they die.

And the women, with some trepidation, enter the tomb that should not be open but somehow is.

We know they won’t find tomb raiders. We know the tomb is empty.

But the women haven’t heard this part of the story before. They’ve never put on their Easter bonnets and sung “Jesus Christ is Risen today” as we do every spring.

They are standing there, burial spices and ointments in hand, wondering what kind of horrible people steal a body, when two men in dazzling clothes appear in their midst.

Why do you look for the living among the dead?”, they ask the terrified women.

As if Jesus’ body being stolen isn’t bad enough. Now two men show up and seem to mansplain the wisdom of their burial rituals.

And this is reason 267 I wasn’t invited to the tomb on Easter morning, because I would have said, “We aren’t looking for the living. Maybe you did not see him die, Mr Fancy Shiny Clothes. But I did. I watched him suffer. And I couldn’t do anything about it. And then I saw his broken body put right here, in this very tomb. So, as soon as you tell me where you’ve put his body, you can take your bedazzled outfits and your ridiculous questions somewhere else.”

Truly, I want to believe one of the women said something like that. But Luke just didn’t write it down.

After Marci Magdalene had her little hissy fit, the men went on to tell the women,

“He is not here, but has risen. Remember how he told you, while he was still in Galilee, that the Son of Man must be handed over to sinners, and be crucified, and on the third day rise again.”

They aren’t instructed to go and tell the other disciples, as recorded in Matthew and Mark. They are just told to remember.
Remember what he taught them.
Remember who he was.
Remember how he loved them.
Remember how he included them.
Remember how he changed everything.
Because he’s really changing everything now. He is not here, but has risen.

And they do remember.

The song Mary sang to them after her visit from the angel and the stories Mary told them about his birth

They remember when he disappeared as a teenager and they found him teaching in the temple, as that were perfectly normal and what was the fuss about anyway?

They remember his baptism by John at the Jordan, when the heavens opened and the Spirit descended on him while the voice from heaven called him the beloved Son.

They remember what it was like to join his band of followers, to hear him teach and be so compelled by his vision for the world that they abandoned their work to follow him.

They remember the miracles, the healings, the nets full of fish, the calming of the storm, the time he ate at the home of a tax collector.

Mary Magdalene remembers her own healing, what it was like to be free of her demons after living with their voices in her head for so many years.

They remember the stories he told, those weird parables that left them wondering about the meaning, learning to live in mystery, without clear answers.

They remember.

We remember too.

We weren’t there that morning. But we have our own stories.

Even if you have not been connected to a church, you have stories that you may not even know are inside you.

Of the time you received grace and mercy when we were expecting judgment.

Or of the time when a near stranger sent a card, or delivered a casserole, offering support or encouragement at the moment we needed it most.

Perhaps you remember the people who taught Sunday school classes, with their flannel board stories of Jesus; or the people who generously invested in your life when they weren’t required to (the way your family is).

We remember the feeling of presence in the quiet of a hospital room, giving us strength to sit vigil through the night at a loved one’s side.

Whatever our experiences may have been, we are called to remember them. And we share them with others, inviting them to listen for the divine presence in their own lives.

We are like the women at the tomb that morning, whose remembering compels them back to the disciples where they testify about what they have seen.

But the women’s testimony seemed to the men to be an “idle tale”. This word in Greek, lairos, only appears this one time in the Bible. And it isn’t a nice word. It means the men received the women’s testimony as the ramblings of delusional, incoherent people.


The women were not, as we know, full of lairos. We know they were reporting their experience back to the disciples who hadn’t been there. We know that without their idle tales, we wouldn’t have accounts of that early morning.

They didn’t tell strangers on the street. They told the other disciples, the one group of people who might possibly have been able to believe such a crazy story. And their story wasn’t believed.

And that is a risk we take, when we remember testify.

We share our experiences, regardless of how they will be received, because the good news refuses to remain in the tomb.

And people may tell us we are full of lairos. And that’s okay. Because our job isn’t to convince anyone.
That is God’s job.

And it is okay when they tell us we are full of lairos because, in fact, it is a startling story when the dead don’t stay dead.  If it doesn’t startle us, are we really paying attention?

People may tell us we are full of lairos. And that’s okay.
Our job is to remember. And then to witness.

Jim Wallis wrote: “Hope unbelieved is always considered nonsense. But hope believed is history in the process of being changed.”

The men may have told the women they were delusional, but as soon as the women went back to the kitchen to prepare breakfast, Peter took off to see for himself. He came home amazed at what he saw.

The women’s story had some importance to Peter, if it was true. He’d just denied Jesus three times before the crucifixion. If what the women said was true, Peter could have feared encountering Jesus. Or he could have had hope that he had another chance to get it right.

It became hope believed for Peter, who went on to be the rock upon which Jesus built the church.

Hope believed is our job, even as people consider it nonsense. Wallis writes:

“It is not nonsense to believe that weapons of mass destruction are not necessary, and that war is not inevitable.

It is not nonsense to believe that a child’s race and class and sex will not always determine their future share of happiness and well-being.

It is not nonsense to believe that we who have been divided from each other can, and will, one day sit down together at the welcome table of God’s love and God’s grace.

These are not nonsense thoughts. With the Easter eyes of resurrection faith, we can see the door through which we too can walk, through which we are invited, where we also will be given the news of the resurrection.

And with this hope, sisters and brothers, we can know our sins forgiven, and our lives made whole. We can look into the faces of our children and believe there is a future for them.

With this hope we can look into the eyes of the poor, the suffering, and the dispossessed and believe that God is able to establish justice for all. With this hope we can together build new communities of faith that will someday overcome the barriers of race and class and gender. And with this hope we can even look forward to a day when our nation no longer measures its security by its weapons, and its status by its wealth.”

Hope, believed, can be a hard thing to hang on to in a world such as ours, full of bad news and difficulty. And I don’t have a perfect answer for how we do it. I just know it is essential that we seek hope, and cultivate and protect its small flame from the winds of despair and chaos.

Maybe we focus in, at a micro level. I can’t fix the ecological disaster today, by myself. But I can reduce my use of plastics, and pick up trash, and pay attention to my own behaviors, and contact my elected leaders asking them to represent us well. Because hope believed is history in the process of being changed.

I can’t end a pandemic, but I can do what I can to limit its spread. Because hope believed is history in the process of being changed.

Gordon at North Rim of Grand Canyon August 2019

As some of you know, my family gathered recently to say goodbye to my father in law, Gordon Glass, who was surely the best father in law ever to live. And my niece, Maya, in her eulogy, shared some words Gordon had written to her in the depths of the pandemic, when she was back at college, but mainly quarantined to her dorm room, filled with anxiety and worry.

Gordon wrote:
“The way forward is not always easy to see in times like this, but I have learned that some things are helpful: do good work, see the next person you encounter as the most important opportunity of your day, and finally know that your background will carry you through these times and you will look back and be stronger for it.
I wish you deep laughs, love every day, and peace right now. Love, Grampa”

I think this is how we hold on to hope when things seem overwhelming.

That’s what the women were doing that morning at the tomb.

They couldn’t fix Rome and its oppressive policies. They couldn’t fix their own religious leaders who handed Jesus over to Rome. They couldn’t stop Jesus’ death on the cross. The world was a big mess for them too.

But they could show up to show him love, even in the face of death.

So this morning we remember these women and their willingness to approach death and tombs to show their love.

We remember the way they encountered new life and remembered the stories of grace and mercy.

We remember how they testified to what they had experienced, willing to bear the accusations of men who told them they were nuts.

And we remember the men who accused them of telling idle tales but then went to see for themselves, so that hope unbelieved could be transformed into history being changed.

As you live into this Easter season, remember and witness, believe in hope. God will do the rest. Thanks be to God. Amen.

PS….. A big thanks to my colleagues at Calvary for making Holy Week so special and for making my job so much fun.

4 thoughts on “Hope Believed

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s